Lessons from the Wisemen

Jeff Garrison
Mayberry and Bluemont Churches
December 28, 2025
Matthew 2:1-12

At the beginning of worship:

There has often been speculation about a fourth wiseman. Gary Larson’s “Far Side,” depicted him rejected at the manger because of his gift, a fruitcake. I happen to like a good fruitcake, so I don’t think that’s as funny as others. 

Henry van Dyke wrote a short story about a fourth wise man.^[1]Artaban, like the other three wisemen, saw a star in the east. He, too, collected gifts, his being gems and pearls, and set out to meet the other wisemen for the journey to find the newborn king. Artaban’s compassion caused him to become sidetracked, which resulted in a longer journey. He barely began his trip when he came across a sick man. Unable to leave him in the road to die, he cared for him and then gave him a sapphire so he could buy medicine and care for himself. The other three are now way ahead of Artaban, but he continues. 

He arrives in Bethlehem around the time of Herod’s killing the innocent boys. He uses another precious stone to bribe the soldiers not to go into a home where a young boy lives. Artaban wonders if he’ll have any presents left when he reaches Jesus. He continues searching and helping those in need. He goes to Egypt as Jesus and his family heads to Nazareth. Artaban keeps looking for Jesus but is always too late. He searches for 33 years. 

Finally, he’s in Jerusalem. Jesus has been led out to Calvary, but even here he stops to help others. He pays the ramson for a slave. Now penniless, he feels he failed, only to meet the risen Christ, who thanks him for his kindness. “What you did for the least of these, you did to me,” Jesus said. Artaban achieved his goal without knowing it. 

Before the reading of Scripture:

As I’ve been doing since Advent, I’m following Matthew’s gospel.^[2] Last Sunday, we heard Matthew’s rather brief reporting on Jesus’ birth. Now, we learn of those who are drawn to Jesus. Luke, in the passage we listened to on Christmas Eve, points to the shepherds. Matthew tells us of the coming of the wisemen. This passage, which brings foreigners to the baby Jesus, foreshadows the ending of Matthew’s gospel where Jesus sends the disciples with his message out to the ends of the earth. 

In his mammoth work, The Birth of the Messiah, the late Raymond Brown, a Roman Catholic New Testament scholar, tells about how after the Protestant Reformation, the Roman Church continued to lift up the tradition of the Magi while we in Protestant Churches focused more on the Shepherds.^[3] While an interesting thought, we should remember Scriptures give equal weight to the shepherds and magi. Both are unlikely candidates to celebrate the birth of a King, just like Mary and Joseph, poor Jewish folk, are unlikely candidates to be the parents of Jesus. God works in mysterious ways.   

Read Matthew 2:1-12

There are several angles I could take to point out the truths contained in the story of the wise men. Let me highlight three and suggest how they apply to our lives:

1. The wise men make it a priority to seek out Jesus.

2. Finding Jesus, they respond giving gifts of thanksgiving, without expecting of anything in return. 

3. Having encountered Jesus, they know their loyalty is to a higher power and ignore the demands of King Herod.

Let’s look at each one. We don’t know why the wise men choose to follow a particular star. We don’t even know who these guys are. It’s generally assumed they’re from Persian. Some scholars suggest Zoroastrian priests who spent time studying the stars. God placed that star, or the conjunction of planets, or an unfamiliar comet, or a supernova, or whatever it was into the skies to catch their attention and to draw them to Judea.^[4]

It’s obvious they are not Jewish; otherwise, they’d know to head to Bethlehem. But whoever they are, they knew something’s up and feel obliged to check it out. This meant taking a long journey to a distant land. It’s important to find Jesus, so they take the risk to seek him. 

Finding Jesus should be that important to us. Responding to Jesus’ call is the most important decision we will make. It should over-ride all our wants and desires. When we decide to seek Jesus out, like the wise men, we’re called on a journey of which we have little control. We’re no longer our own; we belong to our Lord.   

What might we learn from the wisemen’s search? They first head to Jerusalem, the holy city, a place of excitement. Herod’s palace and the temple are there. Pious people pack the street, carrying out the work of the temple. Pilgrims trek there to worship. 

It seems natural to assume Jerusalem would be the place for the birth of a king. But that’s not where they find Jesus! Instead, they’re led to a small dumpy town, five miles away. A poor suburb, inhabited with shepherds and goat herders, supplying meat and animals for the appetites and sacrifices of those in the capital. Flashy isn’t one of God’s traits. God humbled himself by coming to us as Jesus. We often find Jesus, in humble circumstances. To encounter Jesus, we must be humble. Being splashy or hanging out with the popular crowd isn’t a guarantee of Jesus’ presence. Jesus comes to those who humbly admit their needs for a Lord and Savior over their lives.

Now about giving. One of the most important lessons for a Christian to learn is that giving is as much a blessing as it is an obligation. And it’s not just giving money, although the Scriptures are clear the faithful should regularly give our resources for God’s work in the world. But we are also called to be generous with our time and abilities, helping not only the church but also one another. We feel good about ourselves when we give, especially when we give without expecting anything in return. 

Furthermore, when someone does something nice for us, we feel compelled to respond. We may do this simply by saying “thank you” or we may go out of our way to do something nice for the other person. We should also teach our children to be gracious. It’s an important trait for nothing is sadder than someone who is unable to give or acknowledge what someone did for them.

The story of the three wise men shows the importance of giving without being asked and without expecting anything in return. Think about it. A group of foreigners present gifts to a child they don’t know. 

Now let’s now examine our story closely: Contrary to the popular carol and the ubiquitous nativity scenes, we don’t know for sure that there were only three wisemen. Instead, we’re told that they were three gifts and so it’s natural to think of three bearers of the gifts, but they may have been more, that fourth wiseman suggested by Gary Larson and Henry van Dyke. 

Over the years a lot has been made about the three gifts. We naturally associate gold with kings. Fragrant substances, often imported from distant lands, seem fitting for royalty. Myrrh, used in the anointing oil for a priest, aligns with the Messiah, the “anointed one.” Frankincense, used with prayers in the temple, may imply Matthew saw the gift foretelling a time when the baby Jesus would be worshipped as God. However, this is speculation. The gifts may have just been those considered worthy of a King.^[5]

The wise men know they need to worship something greater than themselves. They need to worship God who considers us so precious that he comes in the flesh. In coming, they fulfilled the passage from Isaiah, about the light of Israel arising and the nations and kings coming to see the glory. In fact, from the Isaiah passage, we get the transformation of the wise men into kings.^[6]

In the Old Testament, light often symbolizes the presence of the Lord and salvation. Israel was to be a light to the nations because she had a special relationship with God. The coming of God in Jesus Christ fulfilled Israel’s ability to be that light to all people. The foreign Magi heralded the fulfillment of this prophecy by being the first to worship Jesus.

There is a saying that God cannot pour his blessings into a tight fist.^[7] The wise men were able to be blessed because they came with open hands. But Herod, and the people of Jerusalem, afraid of this thing happening in Bethlehem, were tight fisted. And they missed the glory of Bethlehem.

The wise men express love to the baby Jesus. It was a gamble to go into a foreign land and search out a new king not born in the palace. They take their chances and are remembered today. At the same time, Herod and those in Jerusalem also had a chance to worship the newborn Messiah. But concerned with what they might lose, they lose the opportunity to worship God in the flesh. We remember them, but not for the same reasons. The wise men, who made gifts without expecting anything in return, remind us of our calling as Christians. We’ve been given a great gift. In return, and without expectations, we’re to be generous.   

Finally, consider the loyalty of the wise men to a higher authority. Tying the story of Herod together with the wise men provides us with a counterplot. We’re reminded that even though the Messiah has come, evil remains a seductive threat in the world. Herod’s false humility almost thwarts God’s plan as the wise men, at first, appear to believe his sincerity. The threat of evil is genuine. We can easily find ourselves looking for a Savior in all the wrong places.

Evil has as much power as we give it. Hitler would have never been able to take over Germany and do what he did without the support of others. Nor would any of the other horrific giants in history. They started as wolves in sheep clothing and because not enough people spoke up, soon enough, they carried out their reign of terror.

Of course, God’s Spirit helps the wise men discern Herod’s true intentions. The Magi find the child in Bethlehem, worship and give him gifts. When they leave, they take the bypass around Jerusalem. They remind us that our loyalty is first and foremost to God.^[8] Although as Christians, we’re called to obey those in authority, our allegiance has limits. Our commitment to God always comes first.  

Three things to take home and ponder: Seek Jesus, give graciously, and remember that our loyalty to God trumps all human allegiances. Amen.

---

^[1] William White, Stories for the Journey (Minneapolis Augsburg, 1988), 110-114.

^[2] This is one of the areas the lectionary drives me crazy. It places the flight into Egypt and the killing of the innocent children around Bethlehem this week and the coming of the wisemen on Epiphany, to fall into the 12 days of Christmas. I prefer to preach continually through a passage (Lectio Continua) and so I’m following the Matthew passage on the birth which runs from Matthew 1:18 through chapter 2.  

^[3] Raymond Brown, The Birth of the Messiah (New York: Doubleday, 1993), 197-198.

^[4] Raymond Brown, 167-173, goes into detail about the origin of the wise men and the star.

^[5] Douglas R. A. Hare, Matthew: Interpretation Commentary (Louisville: John Knox Press, 1993), 14.

^[6] See Isaiah 6:1-6 (especially verse 3).  Also see Psalm 72:10-11.  Brown, 187-188, has a detailed account on how the wise men or Magi were transformed into “kings.” 

^[7] John Guest, Beating Mediocrity: Six Habits of the Highly Effective Christian (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1993), 154.

^[8] See Romans 13.